Improve outcomes with this impactful assessment strategy

Learn how to design and implement a portfolio assessment program for your students with this informative resource covering the basics of a successful portfolio program.
Download
Page 2 of 2
Pros and cons of portfolio assessment

Pros:
• They allow the teacher to see the student as an individual, each with his or her own unique set of characteristics, needs, and strengths.

• They transform the role of the teacher away from generating comparative rankings of achievement (grades, percentile rankings, test scores) and toward improving student achievement through evaluative feedback and self-reflection.

• They help teachers standardize and evaluate the skills and knowledge we expect students to acquire without limiting creativity in the classroom.

• They help students be more accountable for the work they do in class and the skills and knowledge we are asking them to acquire.

• They aid in the diversification of approaches to teaching and learning, thus increasing the connections with a wider range of learners and learning styles.

• They involve students in the assessment process, thus giving them a more meaningful role in improving achievement.

• They invite students to reflect upon their growth and performance as learners.

• They involve parents and the community in taking measure of their children's academic achievement in the context of the school curriculum rather than as measured by more ambiguous standardized tests and grades.

Cons:
• They may be seen by some as less reliable or fair than more quantitative or standardized evaluations such as test scores.

• Parents can often be skeptical about measurements other than grades and test scores.

• Most colleges and universities still use test scores and grades as primary admissions criteria.

• They can be time consuming for teachers and staff, especially if portfolios are done in addition to traditional testing and grading.

• Teachers must develop their own individualized criteria, which can be initially difficult or unfamiliar.

• Data from portfolio assessments can be difficult to analyze or aggregate, particularly over long periods of time.

• They are often difficult to integrate meaningfully into school cultures where very high stakes are placed on comparative student ranking and standardized tests.



By Andrew Epstein, Synapse Learning Design

More on Portfolios

Featured High School Resources

TEACHING RESOURCE

Writing Differentiation Strategies and Activities for High School

Close learning gaps this Fall with differentiated writing instruction This resource provides 5 strategies and 2 editabl...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER
Reading Differentiation Strategies and Activities for High School

TEACHING RESOURCE

Reading Differentiation Strategies and Activities for High School

Close learning gaps this Fall with differentiated reading instruction This resource provides 5 strategies and 3 editabl...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER
Math Differentiation and Remediation Strategies for High School

TEACHING RESOURCE

Math Differentiation and Remediation Strategies for High School

Close learning gaps with differentiated and remediated math instruction This resource provides 5 strategies for how to ...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER

Related Resources

Students taking a test

TEACHING RESOURCE

Using Multiple Intelligences in Testing & Assessment

Using Multiple Intelligences in Testing and Assessment Although Howard Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences (MI) i...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER

TEACHING RESOURCE

Portfolios: Types

Portfolios: Types A portfolio in the context of the classroom is a collection of student work that evidences mastery of ...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER

TEACHING RESOURCE

Portfolios: Assessment Strategies

Portfolios: Assessment StrategiesHow does portfolio assessment work? Advisory (Collection) Twice a month, ad...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER

TEACHING RESOURCE

Big Ideas

Big Ideas The first and most essential adaptation is determining what information is most critical for students to learn...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER
Student holding a portfolio

TEACHING RESOURCE

Designing and Implementing a Portfolio Program

Designing and Implementing a Portfolio Program The following set of questions is designed to help teachers and administr...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER

TEACHING RESOURCE

Mediated Scaffolding

Mediated Scaffolding In cognitive scaffolding, the goal is for students to "get it," or understand the first step in the...

Add to Folder
creative writing
children's book
activities
classroom tools
language arts and writing
vocabulary
Create new folderCREATE NEW FOLDER

About the author

TeacherVision Staff

TeacherVision Editorial Staff

The TeacherVision editorial team is comprised of teachers, experts, and content professionals dedicated to bringing you the most accurate and relevant information in the teaching space.

loading gif